Showing posts with label Storm Faerywolf. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Storm Faerywolf. Show all posts

Friday, February 25, 2011

Clarification

I said that if anyone had evidence to contradict what I wrote, to send it to me and I would take it into consideration. Strangely, no one has, though Storm did take the time and effort to write a "refutation." Apparently he discussed colored wands, and alternate colors, on Tribe.net in 2004. (He also says I'm a member of the Feri community there as if that makes a difference, but I didn't even join Tribe.net until ten months after the conversation he references happened. That's on my profile. )

What was discussed on Tribe.net or when it happened is actually not relevant though, and here's why:

I stated in my previous article that discussions of the colored wand system and various permutations of it were perennial; I could, if I wished, probably find evidence that alternatives to the "traditional three" had been bandied about by many people long before 2004. I'm not going to bother, because that has nothing to do with the copyright issues. You don't own an idea based on casual conversation, even Internet conversation; it's only when you sit down, develop it, and write it down as a coherent set of thoughts that it becomes yours. If you reflect a moment you will see why it has to work that way. To show that someone might have been exposed to an idea, you also can't just sit on it; you have to share it in some manner. If Storm had written up a treatment and shared it with others and Elf was aware of it, he might have an argument there...but if that were true, he should have brought it up long before now.

Elf on the other hand did both of those things. The piece of information that is most relevant to all this is that she shared her original write-up with several people, and then discussed writing an article about colored wands for WitchEye with Storm on the telephone (not in e-mail, as he disingenuously implies). Given that he is the owner and editor of WitchEye, that brings in a whole other set of professional ethics and constraints, above and beyond copyright. As an editor, if a writer pitches an article to you, you simply do not take that idea and write it up yourself. Even if you gave them the idea, you don't do that....though they are under an obligation in that case to publish it in your magazine, and you have a right to be upset with them if they publish it elsewhere.

It's also worth noting that Storm previously claimed (in his LiveJournal post) that he had never discussed his ideas about colored wands with anyone except his husband and one unnamed friend. Yet he himself presents evidence that that isn't so. To be charitable, maybe he didn't remember; I certainly don't remember everything I ever wrote on an Internet forum. But in that case he definitely should stop and ask himself if he could be mistaken about a few other things in connection with this.

What Storm should have done is ask Elf if she really wanted to pursue the article, and if she said "no," he could have written his own with a clear conscience. He should still have referenced hers in his own version, because he knew it existed and had discussed it with her. If he really didn't remember talking to her, he should have added a reference once it was called to his attention (as it was, four years ago). That's how a professional writer and editor acts.

Tuesday, February 22, 2011

Clouding the Guardians

by Sarsen

“I myself took an oath in which, among other things, I promised...to protect my 'brothers and sisters in the Craft.'” – “The Secret War of the F(a)eri(e) Tradition” by Storm Faerywolf, WitchEye #11, June 2005

If you look at the site feritradition.org, aside from the headache due to trying to read green-on-black text, you might come away with the impression that the "Feri Tradition" is a conveniently amorphous yet unified entity, and that Storm Faerywolf knows a lot about its practices and history. He does say here and there that the tradition is “diverse,” which is true enough, and sometimes acknowledges that people disagree with him, usually in terms that straw-man their actual objections.However, he buries those statements in his other assertions and in his methods, by speaking grandly and vaguely about “our legends” and other such verbiage as if the tradition came down fully formed from the mists of time, by not giving his sources (or in some cases giving inaccurate or incomplete sources), by....well, pretty much everything else, including the domain name. He does it even with the way the website pages are titled: at the top of the browser window it says, “The Feri Tradition presents 'The Lords of the Outer Dark' featuring the directional guardians engaged by various Feri sects. Come explore!”

The Feri Tradition? I assure you nobody gave him permission to speak for the rest of us; he doesn't even speak to most of us (and that was true long before the split). Not that any initiate would be fooled...but we are not his target audience.

Here I am trying to place plagiarism in a context, to present why I think it's not just ignorance or carelessness, but part of a general policy of de-emphasizing the real sources of ideas or making them invisible so that the presenter can look like an authority. This practice is all too common in the history of Pagan religion, and it is pernicious.

For example...

Here is an excerpt of a Guardian description written by Steven Hewell circa 1982-83 and passed to the Bloodrose line by Gabriel Carillo:

“The Guardian of the East is called the Star Finder, and represents the power of Knowledge. He appears standing before the rising sun. His body is transparent golden yellow, his eyes are two very bright light blue stars, and he had great wings colored pale violet. In his right hand, he holds a rod of sapphire, bound with gold at the top and silver at the bottom.”

There is also a description of the Eastern Guardian as “vaguely humanoid” in an article by Jenny Sill-Holman titled “Who are the Guardians?” which was published in WitchEye #3, August 2000.

Now here is the description from Feritradition.org:

“The StarFinder wields the power of Knowledge. He may appear as vaguely humanoid, his body transparent golden yellow, the color of morning sunlight. His eyes are very bright, light blue stars, and he has enormous wings of pale violet. He stands or flies before the rising sun, his right hand holding a sapphire rod, bound at the top with gold, and bound at the bottom with silver. He may also appear as a slash of soft sunlight, carrying a gentle wind. ” (Faerywolf)

The entirety of it, excepting the last sentence, is drawn from Sill-Holman and Hewell's work, primarily the latter, but without any attribution. This pattern is repeated throughout all of the Guardian descriptions on the page.

From the Korythalia/Bloodrose class notes:

“The Guardian of the South is called the Shining Flame, and represents the power of Truth. He appears in the desert at High noon. His body is transparent ruby red, and he is surrounded by a cloud of fire like the teardrop shape of a candle flame. In his right hand he holds a sword of bright blue metal” (Hewell).

Feritradition.org:

“The ShiningFlame wields the power of Truth. He also may appear in humanoid form, his body transparent ruby red, surrounded by an aura of fire like a teardrop or candle flame. He stands or dances in a desert at noon, holding in his right hand a sword of polished blue metal“ (Faerywolf).

The exact same problems appear throughout the Guardian page; that is, they aren't Faerywolf's at all. They are ninety percent someone else's, usually Hewell or Sill-Holman's, with a few rearranged words and the occasional insertion of a sentence or two of which I do not know the source. Those might actually be original, but (as with Valerie Walker's work) there's no way to tell.

One has to ask...what is the point of this? Why anger one's co-religionists by publishing other people's work without acknowledgment and then putting your own copyright on it? Why engage in that kind of deception, period? Even though the elements from Jenny Sill-Holman's article are minor, that's still a preceding instance of those descriptions in print and it is not mentioned. If the purpose is really to inform people about the tradition, explaining the sources of images and ideas is essential to that purpose. They give context and history, and give people a sense of how the tradition has developed. These are essential to understanding, and also convey the important fact that most of what we now use was written by individuals whom we know within living memory, not by conveniently anonymous ancestors. This is crucial, both for giving credit to the authors and for understanding what material did come from folk tradition and what was passed to Victor Anderson by the Harpy coven. Obscuring any part of the truth there creates an impossible tangle.

I don't care to speculate on other people's motives if I can help it; I don't claim great powers of telepathy.But I can certainly describe the effect of not acknowledging those particular sources. It obfuscates the debt Faerywolf owes to the Bloodrose line, and in particular his predecessors in it. It makes it appear that “the Feri Tradition” has some kind of unified view of the Guardians, instead of a spectrum of personal gnosis regarding them. It occludes the real history, as I mentioned. It also makes it seem like Faerywolf is an authoritative source of information on the topic, instead of merely reproducing what he was given without adding anything much new in the way of commentary, insight, or vision. By putting his copyright on it also, he is claiming the work of others for himself.

In his article “The Lords of the Outer Dark: Exploring the Guardians of the F(a)eri(e) Tradition,” Faerywolf produces similar sleights of hand. He says things like, “Our legends tell us that we do not know if the names we have for them are their own or of those beings to which they hold their allegiance.” I'm not actually sure where that idea comes from; for all I know he made it up in a rare fit of originality. It would probably be more accurate to say, “Some initiates have said at one time or another....” But “legends” sounds so much more ancient, mysterious, portentious, and vague. Likewise when he says, “At one time in our history the names given below (usually referred to as the English names) as well as their post-initiatory counterparts were considered secret...” should be translated as “Up until T. Thorn Coyle published Evolutionary Witchcraft”...that is to say, in the distant epoch of 2005...”the English names of the Guardians were kept by informal custom mainly for student non-initiates to use.” Before that people generally avoided putting them into print; Sill-Holman's article from 2000, for example, never gives any of the names, even though at that time WitchEye was only intended for a small audience of initiates and students. This fact in itself demonstrates how rapidly and radically things have changed.

It's a little dizzying to see Storm citing Ronald Hutton while in the next breath implying that choices made in the last ten years by people he knows personally are ancient history.And seriously, why? According to Steven Hewell, who was there, those original descriptions came out of the creative ferment of Silver Wheel and their work as a coven with the energies of the Guardians...creative ferment being one of our distinguishing characteristics. Any initiate worth his or her salt should be able to come up with something just as powerful and valid. Thorn's work on the same subject is allusive and evocative, but all her own. The members of Silver Wheel...which also included Brian Dragon and Eldri Littlewolf...between them came up with a body of work that is treasured by much of the rest of the tradition. That has been discussed enough to be common knowledge; certainly it is not something that Faerywolf could possibly be unaware of. I do not understand why anyone at this point would wish to replace our real history, full as it is of fascinating, maddening, brilliant people, with a false vagueness. I cannot account for it.

Carillo, Gabriel and Steven Hewell.“Korythalia class notes.” Unpublished mss. 1983.

Faerywolf, Storm. “The Guardians of the Feri Tradition.” www.feritradition.org Accessed February 20, 2011.

Faerywolf, Storm. “The Lords of the Outer Dark: Exploring the Guardians of the F(a)eri(e) Tradition” www.feritradition.org Accessed February 20, 2011.

Hewell, Steven. “The Wheel of the Cloud People.” Unpublished mss. 2000.

Sill-Holman, Jenny. “Who are the Guardians?”WitchEye #3, August 2000.

Monday, February 14, 2011

Plagiarism in the Feri Tradition: Part One

by Sarsen

Plagiarism is nothing new in Pagandom at large; it's practically a shadow tradition in itself, often accompanied by claims of antiquity, “folklore” or quasi-divine authorship to cover the theft. Star Foster has written about it among other people.* However, there has been a push in recent years to grow up and acknowledge the real sources of our traditions, whether they lie in history or the authorship of known persons. This is all to the good. I hope this series will be taken variously as encouragement to read critically and write carefully, a cautionary tale about how much damage casual theft of others' work can cause in a community, and inspiration to Pagan writers (including those who only write for their own spiritual communities) to take the necessary steps to protect their work both before and after it is stolen.

First I think it's important to be clear about what plagiarism is. It is “the use of another's original words or ideas as though they were your own. Any time you borrow from an original source and do not give proper credit, you have committed plagiarism and violated U.S. copyright laws.” (Plagiarism.org) That includes paraphrasing, if you do not acknowledge the source. Furthermore, while some types of quotation or reference are protected by the “fair use” exceptions to copyright law, “there is no magic word count” (Cinque). If a work is short (such as a piece of poetry, liturgy, or a song), quoting any part of it may exceed the bounds of fair use. Also, fair use only allows you to use excerpts and quotes for a number of purposes which include education, parody, or criticism; it does not exempt you from the need to cite your source and attribute properly.

It should also be mentioned that the Copyright Act is a Federal law. While the award of damages to the original author is generally a civil matter, plagiarism is in fact a crime punishable by fines and jail time; depending on the circumstances, it may be considered a misdemeanor, or, in cases where the plagiarist profits from the theft, a felony. (Plagiarism.org) The originator of a work owns copyright, including all rights to reproduce or distribute the work, from the moment of creation, regardless of whether he or she puts a copyright symbol on it, registers it, mails it to him or herself, publishes it, or none of those things. Lack of registration only limits the kinds of damages the author can be awarded in court, not his or her rights with regard to the work. (U.S. Copyright Office) It should be noted also that publication (whether in print or on a website) does not constitute permission to distribute; nor does physically handing over a copy of an unpublished manuscript.

With all that in mind, let us turn to a specific example...

The system of colored wands in the Feri Tradition (also known as Faery, Anderson Feri, and by other names) is a source of longstanding debate; some lines hold that they are rankings based on experience, others view them as representing mastery of certain skills, while others don't use the system at all. During a resurgence of this perennial conversation in 2005, Elf of Elfwreck, then a student of the tradition, came up with an expanded system based on her conversations with her mentor Eldri Littlewolf and the premise that the wands represent different skill sets. Eldri encouraged her to write up her thoughts in handout form, which she did in June of 2005 (Elfwreck 2011); a few months later, Eldri mentioned the idea, along with some specifics, on a private e-mail list, the membership of which included Storm Faerywolf. That e-mail conversation occurred in November of 2005; during it Eldri mentioned that she had been discussing the subject with Elf for about a year. (Littlewolf 2005). In 2006 Elf passed the document around among some initiates. She also recalls a telephone conversation with Storm Faerywolf that year in which she discussed her ideas and the possibility of expanding the handout into an article for publication in WitchEye, which he owns (Elfwreck 2011).

In 2007, Storm published an article in WitchEye #15 titled “The Colors of Power: Exploring the Wands of the F(a)eri(e) Tradition,” presenting, in his words “my own development and interpretation of the wand system in thirteen parts.” It has the appearance of a well-researched piece, including no less than eighteen footnotes with citations. What he doesn't mention is that the idea wasn't his at all; the bulk of his wand correspondences were taken directly from Elf's handout. Neither she nor Eldri are mentioned anywhere in his otherwise copious notes. It is a puzzling omission, especially when one observes that his normal writing style is not to cite anything at all. Aside from numerous other problems with the essay, he conflates the role of “Black Wand” with Grandmaster twice:“the Black being the wand of a Grandmaster” and “The wand of an elder sorcerer, sometimes called a Grandmaster. “ Nobody has ever claimed that merely being given a Black Wand makes you a Grandmaster, even by implication...except for Storm Faerywolf.**

In addition to the common descriptions of the white, green, and black wands, and the concept of an expanded spectrum of colored wands in the first place, there are these specific similarities between Elf's original document and Storm's article as it appeared in WitchEye and on his website:
Elf of Elfwreck, 2005
Storm Faerywolf, 2007
Red wand for sex workers and sacred whores
Red wand for “sex magick”
Yellow wand for loremasters
Yellow wand for teachers
Blue wands for “counselors for other witches, who interface between communities and the Gods.”
Blue for “counselor or mediator...spiritual, psychological, or emotional counseling”
Purple wand for “spirit-workers: trance workers, those who favor possession, dreamers”
Violet wand for those “skilled in various forms of divination and/or psychic techniques”
Rainbow wand for sacred clowns, plus glitter wand for drag queens and children
Iridescent wands for “Queer Mysteries” and tricksters.


The last example might require some explanation, as it may not be obvious to anyone outside of the tradition that the connection between androgyny, tricksters, queerfolk, and children is all via the Fetch (which is specifically mentioned in both explanations). In all cases, the latter version is clearly based on the former, conceptually and in some cases with regard to the specific words used. It should also be noted that these ideas were developed by a student of the tradition (now an initiate) when she formulated them; they therefore, whatever merit they may have on their own, have no basis in the tradition as it was passed down to anyone. The issue there is that, as he himself says, Storm Faerywolf is now passing that material on to “his line,” that is to say his students...without ever having tried the system out to see if it works or it doesn't work. No one actually put the expanded colored wands system to use before he decided to start teaching it to people. Any prospective student of his should stop and wonder how much else he is passing on to them that has never actually been tried out or worked with to see how it functions, if it does, or what hidden pitfalls there may be...as well as how much of it actually came unattributed from someone else.

My father used to say, “a bit dog hollers.” Faerywolf tends to respond quite vehemently to any suggestion that he might be plagiarizing; in a recent LiveJournal post he vociferously denies having done so (while simultaneously, and hilariously, admitting that he did in fact violate copyright and the LiveJournal Terms of Service): “As I originally heard the tale it was supposedly [Elf] whom I had this mythical wand conversation with... and then later I heard it was Eldri and now, years later, I hear it was you...Is there something else that I am forgetting?“

Apparently so. The conversations were with both Eldri and Elf, separately, and as I was on the same e-mail list with Storm and Eldri, I was in fact there for that particular conversation and contributed to it, as did his partner. Furthermore, any assertion that Storm has not been approached privately about this and his other plagiarisms is false; he has been approached multiple times by multiple people over a period of years. The bit wolf hollers.

Author's note: As mentioned, this will be an ongoing series. I intend to cover the examples of plagiarism by Feri initiates of which I am aware; it's absolutely possible that I don't know all of them. If you have documentation of an instance, please let me know.

Works Cited

Cinque, Robert (primary author). “Guide to Fair Use.” National Writers Union. Accessed February 4, 2011. nwu.org

Elfwreck, Elf of. “A Spectrum of Wands.” Unpublished mss. June 2005.

Elfwreck, Elf of. E-mail. January 30, 2011.

Littlewolf, Eldri. E-mail. November 10, 2005.

Faerywolf, Storm. “The Colors of Power: Exploring the Wands of the F(a)eri(e) Tradition.” WitchEye #15, 2007. Accessed February 4, 2011. www.faerywolf.com

Faerywolf, Storm. “Take four!” Eye of the Storm, January 13, 2011. Accessed February 4, 2011. faerywolf.livejournal.com

“Frequently Asked Questions About Copyright.” United States Copyright Office. Accessed February 4, 2011. www.copyright.gov

“Plagiarism FAQs.” Accessed February 4, 2011. www.plagiarism.org

*elorie is me, in case you missed the announcement to that effect.

**Apparently I was mistaken; Steven Hewell's essay on the Feri Tradition which appeared on WitchVox had this to say about wands:

"The White wand is held by all initiates of Feri, each of whom is fully empowered to function in any ritual role and to initiate others into the tradition. The Green Wand signifies our Elders, particularly those who have given much of their time and energy to teaching. The holders of the Black Wand are the Grandmasters of the Feri Tradition (the term is used for either gender); this is a sort of 'lifetime achievement award.'"

Per a recent conversation with Mr. Hewell, that reads as more definitive than he really meant; he was thinking of the difference between "a" Grandmaster and "the" Grandmaster. He also wrote the essay over ten years ago, before he re-established contact with the rest of the tradition and realized that black wands were being handed out so indiscriminately. Hence my confusion. It would be more accurate to say that you have to approach qualification as a Grandmaster before you should be given a black wand.

Cora Anderson's description of a Grandmaster and the qualifications for the title are given here. It's worth noting that no living person meets those requirements.